Limited project slots available for Q3 2026 — secure your formwork engineering support now. Request Consultation →

The Cheapest Elevator Quote Almost Always Costs More — And Three Other Purchasing Mistakes I Made

If you're choosing a vendor based on the bottom-line number on the quote, you're already losing money. Not metaphorically. I mean that literally — I've got the invoices to prove it.

I manage facilities procurement for a developer with 22 hotel and mixed-use properties. From 2018 to 2022, my job description could have been summarized as: get three quotes, pick the cheapest one, move on. That worked right up until it didn't. The two events that forced me to rethink the whole process were: (1) a mid-rise property where our elevator service contract passed to KONE after the original vendor exited the region, and (2) a lobby renovation where I made the same mistake I'd been making all along — just on a smaller, cheaper product line.

Here's what I learned, in order of how much it cost me.

Argument One: An elevator quote is not a price. It's a down payment on a decade of decisions.

The first big surprise came in Q3 2021. We had a property where the maintenance contract had just transitioned to KONE following a regional consolidation. I'd dealt with KONE elevators and escalators in the past, but always at arm's length. This was the first time I had to actually sit in a room with their service team and go line by line through what a coverage agreement meant.

I asked a question I'd never asked a vendor before: "If a part fails on a Tuesday, when does it actually get fixed?"

The answer wasn't a number. It was a map. KONE's service network covered our property, but the specific parts depot for a particular door operator model was about 160 miles away. That meant a 1-to-2 day turn for certain components, not the 4-hour response I'd assumed "24/7 service" implied.

"Service coverage isn't a feature. It's a variable that determines whether your elevator is a vertical transportation system or a very expensive staircase."

The numbers said otherwise. My spreadsheet analysis said the incumbent third-party maintenance vendor was 14% cheaper on an annual basis — about $4,800 less on a 12-month contract. Every line item pointed to staying. Something felt off about their response time on the pre-contract questionnaire. They'd taken nine days to answer three emails during the sales process.

I went with the cheaper option anyway. Six months later, a door operator on one of the property's four elevators failed. The part took 11 days. We ran two elevators on a four-elevator shaft for a week and a half. Lost revenue from the property's ground-floor retail tenants who flagged the bottleneck, plus the operational headache of rerouting guests: roughly $9,200 in measurable impact.

I saved $4,800 and lost $9,200. That is not a math problem. That's a judgment problem — and I got it wrong.

The fix: Now, whenever we're evaluating a KONE elevator locations question or any other service coverage scenario, the first thing we actually compare is parts-delivery time, not price. Industry benchmarks for major OEM parts delivery typically run 2-5 business days; third-party suppliers often run 7-14. If the cheap quote includes a 10-day delivery window, that's not a discount. That's a deferral of cost.

Argument Two: Cheap products have a way of multiplying the cost of everything downstream.

Here's the one that still stings, because I had no excuse. We were renovating the lobby of a 140-room property in early 2022. I ordered 1,400 linear feet of solid oak baseboard trim from a supplier who undercut our usual vendor by about 22%. Total order came in at roughly $2,400. Delivery was fast. I felt good about it.

Then the installers started opening boxes. About 35% of the runs had visible warping — enough that the finish carpenter refused to install them. That's 490 linear feet of trim we couldn't use. The baseboard trim order had to be re-placed, and because we were on a compressed timeline, the re-order went to the original vendor at full price. Meanwhile, the painters and flooring crew couldn't finish their work in three of the lobby zones. We paid for three idle labor days.

Final math: $2,400 in bad trim, $1,180 in idle labor, $2,600 in the re-order. The "savings" of about $680 evaporated into a $4,200 lesson about a product that costs less than most people spend on lunch for a week.

Same pattern showed up with our events team, who sourced highball glasses for a lobby bar launch through a low-bid online supplier. Forty-eight glasses arrived; eleven were chipped or cracked. The re-order took eight days. The bar launch went ahead with mismatched stemware. Not a disaster, but a $380 redo on a $620 order — and a dent in the kind of polish we're supposed to project.

Why does this keep happening? Because procurement is trained to compare unit prices, and unit prices don't capture variance risk. A 35% defect rate on baseboard trim isn't visible on a spreadsheet. It's visible on a job site, three days before a deadline.

Argument Three: The pattern crosses categories entirely — even the ones you think are too simple to get wrong.

I want to tell you about the salt and stone order because it's the cleanest example of how this thinking becomes a habit. Our grounds contractor handles winter de-icing. In late 2022, I approved a switch to a cheaper supplier for the salt and stone mix we use on walkways. The question in my head was literally "where to buy salt and stone" — as if location was the decision. It took six weeks for the first delivery. The original supplier had been doing next-week delivery for four years. We didn't run out — barely — but I spent a month checking inventory every Monday morning, which is not what I want to be doing at 7 a.m.

The purchase price difference was around $1,900 for the season. The cost of my time, plus the one-week emergency top-up order at a premium, roughly $2,100. Net loss, plus stress.

Argument Four: "But we can't always afford the premium option."

I hear this from new hires, and I get it. I've been the guy defending the budget. But the question isn't "premium vs. budget." It's "how do I know the budget option is actually cheaper?" And the honest answer is: you don't, until you've priced in three things most quotes leave off.

  • Service coverage. Who fixes this, from where, and how fast?
  • Variance risk. What percentage of orders need rework, and who eats that cost?
  • Downtime exposure. If this product underperforms, what's the cost per day?

When I added those three columns to our evaluation template, the picture changed completely. Some premium options got cheaper on a total-cost basis. Some cheap options got much, much more expensive. The ranking flipped for roughly one in four vendors we evaluated.

Am I saying always buy the premium option? No. I'm saying the premium option earns its place, and the cheap option has to earn it too. Most cheap options haven't earned it. They just look like they have because nobody asked the right questions during the sales cycle.

What I actually changed — and what I'd tell you to copy

In mid-2023, after the third project in 18 months went sideways on a low-bid purchase, I sat down and built a pre-check list for our team. It's eleven items long. The first five aren't about money at all. They're about whether the vendor can actually deliver what the quote implies: parts availability, service radius, defect rate history, response-time commitment in writing, and total cost per year of ownership.

We've caught 47 potential errors with this checklist in the past 18 months — or, more honestly, 51; I'd have to recount the log. Some of them were small. A few would have been $10k+ problems. One of them was an elevator tender where the three "lowest" bids all had service radii that excluded our property, and we hadn't noticed because we'd been comparing equipment prices instead of agreements.

Does it feel bureaucratic? Sometimes. Do I still walk back to my desk after signing a contract and think, "Did I just commit to the wrong number?" Absolutely — I did it two weeks ago on a baseboard trim re-order, of all things, and the two weeks until delivery were stressful. But the payoff showed up in the numbers: our per-property rework incidents dropped from an average of 3.2 per year to under 1.

The bottom line, and I'll say it without hedging: the lowest quote isn't a shortcut. It's the most expensive way to learn procurement. Compare total cost. Confirm the service radius. Ask what happens on a Tuesday when something breaks. Then — and only then — look at the price on the page.

Leave a Reply